Kosher and halal diets are typical dietary patterns based on Jewish and Islamic legal principles.
Both kosher and halal diets establish tight standards for which foods are permitted and prohibited based on religious beliefs.
Many people, however, need clarification of how these two diets vary.
This article examines some similarities and differences between halal and kosher diets.
Basics of each diet
Kosher refers to foods prepared in line with traditional Jewish dietary regulations.
A kosher diet forbids certain food combinations, and only certain animal products may be consumed (1).
On the other hand, the term halal is used to designate permissible meals under Islamic law as established by the Quran, Islam’s canonical scripture.
Halal diets establish stringent criteria for how animals are bred, killed, and prepared before consumption (2).
Some items are branded as certified kosher or certified halal, indicating that they follow the regulations of the respective diets.
A kosher diet restricts food pairings
A kosher diet divides foods into three categories: meat (fleishig), dairy products (milchig), and pareve, which refers to foodstuffs that do not contain meat or dairy.
Kosher standards prohibit the consumption of meat and dairy meals at the same meal (3).
Additionally, kitchen tools and equipment used to make meat and dairy should be kept separate.
Halal diets, on the other hand, contain no restrictions or limitations surrounding food pairings.
Both have some restricted foods
Certain items are forbidden in both halal and kosher diets.
Dishes containing blood, alcohol, and foods cooked with it, and certain types of meat, including pork, most reptiles, birds of prey, and predatory animals, are prohibited in Halal diets (2).
A kosher diet also prohibits meat consumption from pigs, horses, rabbits, kangaroos, camels, and squirrels.
Fish without fins and scales, such as shellfish, are likewise prohibited, as are predatory or scavenging birds, such as hawks and eagles.
Furthermore, the hindquarters of animals are only sometimes deemed kosher. This comprises beef cuts such as flank, sirloin, round, and shank steaks (4).
Both regulate the slaughtering of animals
The halal and kosher diets contain rules about how to kill meat before eating.
Kosher meat must be killed by a shohet, a person trained to slaughter animals in line with Jewish regulations.
Meats must also be soaked to remove all blood before cooking (5).
Animals must be healthy during slaughter and slaughtered using a precise procedure that entails severing the jugular vein, according to halal requirements.
To be deemed halal, the name of Allah must be uttered at the time of slaughter (2, 6).
Because of similarities in slaughtering techniques, kosher-certified meat may be considered halal in some situations.
The bottom line
Kosher and halal diets establish rigorous food standards acceptable under Jewish and Islamic law.
Both diets have unique regulations surrounding the animal killing, and both prohibit certain types of meat.
However, halal diets forbid some meals, such as those containing alcohol or blood, while kosher diets restrict particular food combinations.
0 Comments